How to Lead When the Room Turns Toxic

The Coffee Bean Leader

I told Jana a story once about three things you can drop in a pot of boiling water.

A potato goes in hard and comes out soft. That's how you make mashed potatoes. An egg goes in soft and comes out hard. A coffee bean goes in, and the water changes. You get coffee.

Same water. Same heat. Three completely different results, and only one of them makes the kitchen smell better.

It's an old story, and nobody seems to know who told it first. I've always liked it because it doesn't pretend the water isn't hot. Every team, every family, every business hits boiling water eventually. The only question is what the heat turns you into.

Jana's in some boiling water right now. That's what this week's episode is about.

When a group turns

Jana is part of a group made up of people who are all there for the same reason: to learn, grow, and become better leaders. And lately, as she put it on the show, she has seen the dark side of leadership up close.

We opened the episode by calling it Living Lucky® Therapy. Then I clarified, mostly for our lawyers, that it is not therapy. Jana said it's her therapy. We settled on "a coaching session, in a sense."

You can tell a group has gone toxic by how your body feels when you leave it. Tight stomach. Shoulders up around your ears. A vague sense that you just ate something from the back of the fridge. If that keeps happening, you're taking in that dynamic every time you show up, and that's what toxic means.

And there's a pattern that makes it worse. Somebody brings bad blood into the room (Taylor Swift has a song about this, I'm told), and someone else reflects it right back. Tone for tone. Blame for blame. Tit for tat.

I hear people say, "I just met them how they met me," like it's a principle. It's a strange way to go through life. It means whoever is in the worst mood gets to decide how everybody else behaves.

Jana's answer, from the show: when someone comes at you with that pointed energy, blaming, shaming, deflecting, you block it, rise above it, and send back something better. That one move can flip a whole room.

Lead like an umpire

Jana says we all learn leadership from our role models growing up, and hers was her dad.

He was a high school basketball coach and a teacher at the same school, and a serious athlete in his own right. Jana watched him lead teams for years, and she watched how he handled the hard part.

When a parent came storming in wanting to know why their kid wasn't getting minutes, he never had that conversation on the court after the game. He took it into a side room. Praise in public, correct in private. He protected people's dignity, including the dignity of the parent who was being difficult.

And he had a phrase: lead like an umpire. Firm, fair, open, and objective.

An umpire doesn't call a strike because the batter looked disappointed. He doesn't change the call because the crowd booed. He makes it and stands on it.

You can still be wrong, though. The word "decide" comes from a Latin root that means to cut off, and when you decide, you cut off the other options. But you can always say, "I was wrong, because I know more now." That isn't wishy-washy. Wishy-washy is changing your call because someone got loud. Growing is changing it because you learned something.

  The Potato The Egg The Coffee Bean
In boiling water Goes in hard, comes out soft Goes in soft, comes out hard Changes the water
As a leader Wishy-washy, avoids hard calls Rigid, cold, loses compassion Clear, warm, decides ahead of time
What the team gets Confusion Burnout A better room

Soft, hard, or coffee

Back to the pot.

A potato leader lets the pressure turn them soft. They start second-guessing decisions, avoiding hard calls, and trying to keep everyone happy, until nobody knows what the plan is.

An egg leader lets the pressure turn them hard. They might stay directional for a while, and people will follow for a while. But they lose their compassion, and eventually they burn people out. Nobody sticks around for a hard-boiled boss.

A coffee bean leader changes the water. They don't absorb the panic or the sarcasm in the room. They decide ahead of time what they're there to create, and then they bring it. That's contagious, in the good way.

I said on the show, "Who doesn't want to be the coffee bean?" And then I realized nobody has ever volunteered to be the potato.

The group that taught her

Jana has been in the leader's seat and missed, and she's open about it.

Years ago she started an a cappella group called YELLA. She attracted five very talented singers, and they were good. Really good. The biggest stage they played was the House of Blues at Universal Studios.

But Jana had no idea how to run an organization. She didn't always feel like the most talented person in the room, which made it harder to lead. And she found out the group was teaching her a lot more about leadership than it was about singing.

If YELLA had gone smoothly, she'd have learned a lot about harmonies and not much else. As she put it, she'd be the star of Pitch Perfect by now. (I asked on the show whether people still do a cappella, and whether "a cappella-ing" is a verb. Neither of us knows.)

Failure is tuition. The lesson is in there, as long as you can take your eye off the part that hurt long enough to find it.

Shortly after YELLA ended, when Jana was around 38, she did some honest self-examination about how she could have led that group better. What she came away with is the line she closed the episode on: the more I can lead myself, the better I am in every area of my life.

She also believes something I've seen proven over and over. Sometimes the best leaders emerge from the middle. Not out front, not in the back. From the middle, which is right where she is now.

The four-question reset

So what do you do when the water's already boiling?

Take a pause. Take a big breath. And then, as Jana said when we were off the air, get everyone to agree on why they're there in the first place. Her other piece of advice: don't lose the fun. When everyone gets that serious, they've usually forgotten the reason they joined.

Then run our morning questions, the 4-Minute Luck Activation Formula, on the group itself. Each person answers for themselves, and then you answer together.

Answer alone first. Then together.

What do we want to experience here?

How do we want to grow?

How do we each want to contribute?

How lucky are we to have this?

Afterward, use the evening questions, the 4-Minute Reflection Formula, on your own part in it. What did I do well in that meeting? What MIGHT I have done differently? How will I be more effective next time? How lucky am I to be in a room full of people trying to grow?

Run them together and that's the Living Lucky® Loop. There's no wrong way to do it. Use it before one tense meeting, or across a whole season of a group that's struggling. It's how a coffee bean decides what kind of coffee to make before it ever hits the water.

The Living Lucky® Practice

Exercise: Think of the last time you were in boiling water with a group. Write down whether you went soft, went hard, or changed the water.

Reflection question: Where am I meeting people "how they met me" instead of how I want to show up?

Journal prompt: What's one correction I've made in public that belonged in a side room? What would it have sounded like in private?

Action: Before your next tense meeting, answer the first question for yourself: What do I want to experience here? Bring that answer in with you.

Questions people ask about this

What is the potato, egg, and coffee bean metaphor in leadership?

It's a story about how people respond to pressure, or "boiling water." A potato goes in hard and comes out soft, like a leader who becomes indecisive and people-pleasing. An egg goes in soft and comes out hard, like a leader who becomes rigid and cold. A coffee bean changes the water itself, like a leader who uses clarity and warmth to lift the whole room.

How do you stop a toxic tit-for-tat cycle on a team?

Refuse to mirror what's coming at you. Notice the tension in your body, hold a clear boundary, and answer with calm and clarity instead of matching the sarcasm, blame, or cold tone. When one person stops playing, the cycle loses its fuel.

How do you reset a team that has lost its sense of purpose?

Pause the drama and ask four questions, first individually and then together: What do we want to experience here? How do we want to grow? How do we each want to contribute? How lucky are we to have this? It moves the focus off the friction and back to why everyone showed up.

What does "praise in public, correct in private" mean?

Celebrate people where others can see it, and handle corrections one-on-one. Correcting someone in front of the group creates shame and costs you trust. A private conversation protects their dignity and usually gets a better result.

What does it mean to lead like an umpire?

Be firm, fair, open, and objective. Make the call, stand on it, and don't change it because someone got upset. You can still change your mind later when you learn something new. That's growth, not being wishy-washy.

How do I know if a group has become toxic?

Pay attention to how you feel when you leave. If you regularly walk out tense, drained, or a little sick, and people are trading blame or sarcasm instead of working on the goal, the dynamic has turned toxic. The fix starts with how you choose to show up in it.

If you'd like help leading yourself, or a team that's in boiling water right now, that's what our coaching is for, at livinglucky.com. The Decision Matrix, The Quiet Space, and our journals are on Amazon under Jana and Jason Shelfer, and at livinglucky.com. And subscribe to our YouTube channel so you never miss an episode.

Hear the whole conversation on the Living Lucky® Podcast with Jana and Jason Shelfer, Season 11, Episode 60: "The Coffee Bean Leader."

Listen on Spotify or watch on YouTube.

We Create Our Luck®.


Next
Next

Is Your Energy Pushing People Away?